Grateful Bakes Menu
All baked goods are made to order!
*Please note: Custom Orders Welcome! Grateful Bakes is always happy to custom design a cake just for you.
Pricing
Cakes
- 4″ mini cakes (serves 4 – 6) – $35+
- 6″ round cakes (serves 8 – 12) – $55+
- 8″ round cakes (serves 16 – 24) $75+
- 10″ round cakes (serves 38) $100+
- 12″ round cakes (serves 56) $125+
- Larger cakes & Tiered cakes – call for pricing (216) 789.4783
Cupcakes
Mini cupcakes
- $15 per dozen (standard flavors + decorating)
- $25 per dozen with custom decorations (flowers, succulents, etc.)
Full size cupcakes
- $30 per dozen
- $48 per dozen with with custom decorations (flowers, succulents, etc.)
Pies: $35+
Cake Truffles: $25/dozen
Cake Menu
Sweet Jane
- Vanilla cake with Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting
$
35 and up
Chocolate Chocolate
- Devil′s Food Cake (rich chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream)
$
35 and up
Chocolate Jane
- Chocolate cake with vanilla bean buttercream
$
35 and up
Reese’s Witherspoon
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
$
35 and up
German Chocolate
- German Chocolate Layer Cake (deeply chocolatey cake filled with chocolate buttercream and brown butter custard with toasted pecans and shredded coconut. Fun fact: not actually German!)
$
35 and up
Carrot Carrot
- Like regular carrot cake, but with a more complex, deeper flavor from the browned butter and spices!
$
35 and up
Loretta
- Red Velvet layer cake filled with cream cheese buttercream
$
35 and up
Coconut Dream
- Coconut cake with coconut buttercream. Optional: dark chocolate ganache filling.
$
35 and up
Dulce de Leche
- Vanilla bean cake with dulce de leche filling & buttercream.
$
35
Pistachio Pistachio
- Pistachio cake with creamy pistachio custard, crushed pistachios, and vanilla bean buttercream.
$
35 and up
Flower Girl
- Lavender Rose Cake (vanilla bean cake, lavender rose simple syrup soak, raspberry lavender rose jelly filling, rose buttercream)
$
35 and up
Piña Colada
- Piña Colada Cake (pineapple coconut cake, coconut rum + pineapple syrup soak, fresh pineapple curd filling, coconut rum pineapple buttercream)
$
35 and up
Chocolate Mint Chip
- Chocolate cake filled and frosted with mint chocolate chip buttercream
$
35 and up
Bananas! (split)
- Banana cake filled with alternating layers of strawberry sauce drizzled with chocolate sauce and pineapple sauce
$
35 and up
Cleveland Cassata
- Light and fluffy sponge cake layered with vanilla bean Italian custard and fresh strawberries with a chantilly cream frosting
$
35 and up
Chocolate Raspberry
- Chocolate cake filled with Raspberry Mascarpone mousse
$
35 and up
Vanilla Raspberry
- Vanilla bean cake filled with Raspberry Mascarpone mousse
$
35 and up
Lemon Love
- Light and fluffy lemon sponge cake filled with lemon curd + lemon buttercream
$
35 and up
Chocolate Rum Hazelnut
- Chocolate cake with rum syrup soak, filled with toasted hazelnuts and chantilly cream frosting
$
35 and up
Nina
- Chocolate cake, Nutella buttercream, dark chocolate ganache drip
$
35 and up
Pete’s Chocolate Dream
- Chocolate cake with creamy almond filling, Nutella buttercream, and dark chocolate ganache drip
$
35 and up
Moose! (Mousse)
- Chocolate mousse cake
$
35 and up
Crunchy Moose! (Mousse)
- Chocolate mousse cake With toffee crunch & salted bourbon caramel
$
35 and up
Brittany
- Vanilla almond butter cake with cannoli filling (cannoli filling contains pistachios and mini chocolate chips)
$
35 and up
Tropical Florida
- Pineapple cake with pineapple syrup soak, filled with fresh pineapple curd and mango puree reduction, frosted with mango buttercream
$
35 and up
Tropical Tres Leches
- Tres Leches cake with coconut mango cream and fresh fruit
$
35 and up
Chocolate Grandma
- Chocolate cake with orange Grand Marnier syrup soak and orange Grand Marnier buttercream
$
35 and up
Orange Grandma
- Orange cake with orange Grand Marnier syrup soak and orange Grand Marnier buttercream
$
35 and up
Apple Crisp
- Layers of spice cake with apple cider syrup soak, filled with apple pie filling, crunchy ″crisp″ crumbles, salted bourbon caramel, frosted with brown butter brown sugar buttercream
$
35 and up
Birthday Party
- Milk Bar style birthday layer cake: Vanilla confetti cake, vanilla milk soak, filled with birthday cookie crumbles and birthday cake frosting
$
35 and up
Apple Pie
- Milk Bar style apple pie layer cake: Brown butter cake with apple cider syrup soak, filled with liquid cheesecake, pie crust crumbles, and cinnamon spice flecked apple pie filling, brown butter brown sugar buttercream
$
35 and up
Pumpkin Pie
- Layers of spice cake with vanilla milk soak, filled with pumpkin pie filling, pie crust crumbles and pumpkin ganache, pumpkin pie frosting and toasted pumpkin seeds
$
35 and up
Key Lime Pie
- Milk Bar style key lime pie layer cake: layers of key lime graham cracker cake, sour cream buttercream, graham cracker crumbles, and key lime curd
$
35 and up
More than a Cookie!
- Chocolate Chip Cookie layer cake: Layers of chocolate chip cake filled with edible cookie dough, vanilla bean buttercream, and chocolate chip cookie crumbles. Glass of milk not included
$
35 and up
Cupcake Menu
Award Winning Cupcakes!
Chocolate Chocolate
- chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Chocolate Vanilla
- chocolate cake, vanilla buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Vanilla Vanilla
- vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Vanilla Chocolate
- vanilla cake, chocolate buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Chocolate Caramel
- chocolate cake, salted bourbon caramel buttercream + caramel drizzle
$
15/dozen and up
Blondie
- vanilla cake, salted bourbon caramel buttercream + caramel drizzle
$
15/dozen and up
Chocolate Mousse Crunch
- chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse, chocolate buttercream, toffee crunch, salted bourbon caramel drizzle
$
20/dozen and up
Reese’s Witherspoon
- chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Nina
- chocolate cake, Nutella buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
German Chocolate
- chocolate cake, German chocolate frosting, chocolate ganache drizzle
$
15/dozen and up
Jolene
- vanilla cake, strawberry buttercream, strawberry drizzle
$
15/dozen and up
Chocolate Strawberry
- chocolate cake, strawberry buttercream, strawberry drizzle
$
15/dozen and up
Vanilla Raspberry
- vanilla cake filled with raspberry jam, raspberry buttercream
$
20/dozen and up
Chocolate Raspberry
- chocolate cake filled with raspberry jam, raspberry buttercream
$
20/dozen and up
Coconut
- coconut cake, coconut buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Pistachio
- pistachio cake, vanilla bean buttercream, pistachio crumbles
$
15/dozen and up
Carrot Carrot
- brown butter carrot cake, cream cheese buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Loretta
- red velvet cake, cream cheese buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Brittany
- chocolate or vanilla almond cake, cannoli frosting (contains pistachios and chocolate chips), topped with pistachio crumbles and mini chocolate chips
$
15/dozen and up
Tea Time
- Earl Grey cake, lavender white chocolate buttercream, biscuit crumbles
$
15/dozen and up
Annabelle
- lemon cake, ginger buttercream, topped with crystalized ginger
$
15/dozen and up
Lemon Love
- lemon cake filled with lemon curd, lemon buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Lemon Raspberry
- lemon cake filled with raspberry jam, lemon buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Lemon Basil
- lemon cake filled with lemon curd, basil buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Apple Crisp (seasonal)
- spice cake filled with apple pie filling, brown butter brown sugar buttercream, crisp crumbles, salted bourbon caramel drizzle
$
20/dozen and up
Pumpkin Pie (seasonal)
- spice cake filled with pumpkin pie filling, pumpkin pie buttercream, crisp crumbles, salted bourbon caramel drizzle
$
20/dozen and up
Eggnog Latte (seasonal)
- eggnog cake, eggnog and mocha buttercream swirled together
$
15/dozen and up
Honey Spice w/Pear & Ginger (seasonal)
- honey cake filled with pear puree reduction, ginger buttercream, topped with crystalized ginger
$
20/dozen and up
Cranberry Orange (seasonal)
- cranberry orange cake, orange buttercream
$
15/dozen and up
Peppermint Patti Smith (seasonal)
- chocolate cake, peppermint buttercream, topped with crushed candy canes
$
15/dozen and up
Pies
Pie Menu
Brown Butter Pumpkin
$
35
Traditional Apple
- Dutch or double crust
$
35
Blushing Apple
- made with apples and beets
$
35
Apple Rose
$
35
Apple Ginger
$
35
Pecan
$
35
Chocolate Pecan
$
35
Sweet Potato
$
35
Junipear
- juniper pear
$
35
Bourbon Pear Crumble
$
35
Maple Buttermilk Custard
$
35
Sweet Corn Custard (seasonal)
$
35
Black Bottom Oatmeal
$
35
Buttered Rum Cream
$
35
Plum Fig (seasonal)
$
35
Salty Honey
$
35
Cranberry Sage (seasonal)
$
35
Lavender Honey Custard
$
35
Pistachio Coconut Cream
$
35
Coconut Cream
$
35
Lemon Meringue
$
35
Chocolate Silk
$
35
Triple Berry
$
35
Blueberry
$
35
Strawberry Balsamic
$
35
Strawberry Rhubarb (seasonal)
$
35
Peach (seasonal)
$
35
Paprika Peach (seasonal)
$
35
Cherry (seasonal)
- traditional or streusel topped
$
35
Bourbon Pumpkin Cheesecake
$
35
Cake Truffles
Birthday Cake
- vanilla confetti cake, vanilla milk soak, white chocolate coating, confetti cookie crumb ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Red Velvet
- red velvet cake, cream cheese buttercream, white chocolate coating, confetti cookie crumb ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Chocolate Chip Passion Fruit
- vanilla cake, chocolate chips, passion fruit puree, white chocolate coating, vanilla cookie crumb ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Chocolate Peanut Butter
- chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream, dark chocolate coating, crushed peanuts
$
25/dozen
Chocolate Malt
- chocolate cake, malted milk soak, white chocolate coating, malted milk crumb ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Apple Pie
- brown butter cake, apple pie compote, white chocolate coating, pie dough ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Popcorn
- popcorn cake, popcorn infused milk, white chocolate coating, popcorn ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Dulce de Leche
- dulce de leche cake, dulce de leche soak, white chocolate coating, cookie milk ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Strawberry Lemon
- lemon cake, lemon juice, white chocolate coating, strawberry ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Coconut Tangerine
- coconut cake, tangerine confit, white chocolate coating, toasted coconut
$
25/dozen
Coconut Lime
- coconut cake, lime confit, white chocolate coating, toasted coconut
$
25/dozen
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
- coconut cake, pineapple juice, white chocolate coating, toasted coconut and vanilla cookie crumb ″sand″
$
25/dozen
German Chocolate
- chocolate cake, almond butter brown sugar milk, white chocolate coating, toasted coconut & crushed pecans
$
25/dozen
Pretzel Pretzel
- pretzel cake, milk soak, white chocolate coating, pretzel ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Mint Cookies ‘n Cream
- vanilla cake, chocolate chips, mint liquid cheesecake, white chocolate coating, chocolate cookie ″sand″
$
25/dozen
Tough Cookie
- vanilla cake, vanilla orange soak, white chocolate coating, vanilla orange ″sand″
$
25/dozen